Psychedelia.dk
https://psychedelia.dk/forum/

("super")string*-teorien er uvidenskabelig og fork
https://psychedelia.dk/forum/viewtopic.php?f=12&t=7462
Side 1 af 1

Forfatter:  Astral [ 10 mar 2004 14:13 ]
Titel:  ("super")string*-teorien er uvidenskabelig og fork

http://www.newscientist.com/opinion/opi ... id=ns23811

João Maguei
Citat:
string theory is really over-hyped. It is possible that the final answer has something to do with string theory, but it certainly doesn't look that way if you just look at what they've achieved so far. String theory is so far removed from experiment, from anything that can be tested, that it isn't really a scientific theory the way it is.

There are some very good ideas that have come out of it, but they are really like toy models, fine ideas - they are not physical theories. That's OK, I would not have said what I said if they were happy just playing their game. But string theorists dress the whole idea up as if it were the final answer to everything. They think that nothing else should be done. And so I think they should get some stick. I work in string theory myself, but I just think it wrong to put all your shares into string theory because it's very unlikely to be the final answer.

Forfatter:  Has Oak [ 10 mar 2004 16:18 ]
Titel: 

Ja, det er jo ikke overraskende at folk er uenige.

Astral, ham du citerer skriver jo ikke at string teorien er forkert. Han siger at den måske kan blive en del af et endeligt svar. Desuden holder den matematisk. Eller det var ihvertfald mit indtryk efter at have set dette udemærkede program: http://www.channel4.com/science/microsi ... heory.html

Side 1 af 1 Alle tider er UTC + 1 time [DST ]
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group
https://www.phpbb.com/